Check

A Home in New York and a Home in Nevada or Florida

Which state taxes you when you keep homes in both?

Last updated: November 2026  |  By the Domicile365 Editorial Team


The Short Answer

Owning homes in two states does not split your tax between them. Each state applies its own residency rules, and New York's reach is the one that matters here: a New York resident is taxed on all income from every source, while a nonresident is taxed only on income from New York sources. Nevada and Florida have no personal income tax, so for someone with a home in New York and a home in one of those states, the whole question is whether New York can treat you as a resident.

New York can do that in two separate ways. Passing one test does not protect you from the other:

  • Domicile. New York is still your permanent, primary home.
  • Statutory residency. Your domicile is elsewhere, but you keep a permanent place of abode in New York for substantially all of the year and spend 184 days or more in New York.

The same rules apply whether the second home is in Nevada, Florida, Texas, Tennessee or any other state. The no-income-tax states simply make the outcome more expensive, for the reason explained below. For Nevada's own rules, see Nevada Tax Residency Rules. For the full New York rules, see New York State and New York City Residency Basics.

Four Common Situations

Your factsHow New York treats youWhat New York taxes
New York is still your domicile; the Nevada or Florida home is a second homeResident, however few days you spend in New York (two narrow exceptions aside)All income, from every source
Domicile moved to Nevada or Florida; you kept the New York home and spend 184 days or more in New YorkStatutory residentAll income, from every source
Domicile moved to Nevada or Florida; you kept the New York home and spend 183 days or fewer in New YorkNonresidentNew York-source income only
Domicile moved to Nevada or Florida; you no longer keep a home in New YorkNonresidentNew York-source income only

The two exceptions in the first row are the 30-day and 548-day rules for New York domiciliaries, which apply only on specific facts. They are described in the New York residency basics article.

Test One: Which Home Is Your Domicile?

You can have several residences but only one domicile. It is the place you intend to be your permanent home and to return to whenever you are away. A New York domicile continues until you show, by clear and convincing evidence, that you gave it up and established a new one somewhere else. The person claiming the change carries that burden, so someone who moved from New York to Nevada or Florida has to prove the move; New York does not have to disprove it.

New York's Nonresident Audit Guidelines direct auditors to compare your two homes on five primary factors:

  • Home: the size, value and use of each residence, and which one you treat as home;
  • Active business involvement: where you work and where you manage your business interests;
  • Time: where you spend your days over the year;
  • Near and dear: where you keep the possessions that matter most to you;
  • Family: where your spouse and minor children live and go to school.

A Nevada or Florida driver's license, voter registration and vehicle registration are expected, but auditors treat them as formalities. They support a move; they do not prove one. Florida also lets you record a Declaration of Domicile, which has the same limited weight. In Matter of Hoff, a couple with a Florida home, Florida licenses, Florida voter registration and a filed declaration were still held to be New York domiciliaries, largely because they spent more days in New York than in Florida and kept their New York home, business and club ties. See Leaving New York: How to End New York Tax Residency.

Test Two: Statutory Residency

Even if Nevada or Florida is clearly your domicile, New York taxes you as a resident for any year in which both of the following are true (N.Y. Tax Law § 605(b)(1)(B)):

  1. you maintain a permanent place of abode in New York for substantially all of the taxable year; and
  2. you spend 184 days or more in New York during the year.

This rule is often called the "183-day rule," but 183 days is the most you can spend, not the trigger. See The 183-Day Rule Explained.

Is the New York home a permanent place of abode?

A permanent place of abode is a dwelling suitable for year-round use that you maintain, whether you own it or rent it. Two court decisions narrowed the definition: under Matter of Gaied (2014) and Matter of Obus (2022), you must have a residential interest in the dwelling, meaning a real relationship to it as a place you live, not just ownership or payment of the bills. That is a fact question, and limited use of a second home is not an automatic exemption. Since tax year 2022, the Audit Division has generally read "substantially all of the year" as more than 10 months (Nonresident Audit Guidelines, pp. 49–51). An apartment kept "just for visits" will usually qualify.

How are the days counted?

Any part of a day in New York generally counts as a full day (20 NYCRR § 105.20(c)). Flying in for a dinner counts. So does a morning in New York before an afternoon flight to Las Vegas or Palm Beach. The exceptions are narrow: presence solely to board a plane, train, ship or bus to a destination outside New York, or travel through the state on the way somewhere else, and certain days as a hospital inpatient. See Transit Days and Tax Residency and What Counts as a Day for Tax Residency.

New York City is counted separately

New York City applies the same two tests using a home and days in the five boroughs. Someone with a Manhattan apartment needs a City day count as well as a State one. Someone whose New York home is in the Hamptons or Westchester can be a State resident without being a City resident.

Why a No-Income-Tax State Raises the Stakes

When two states tax the same income, the state of residence generally gives a credit for tax paid to the other state on income sourced there. That credit is what softens the result for someone with homes in, say, New York and Connecticut. Nevada and Florida charge no personal income tax, so there is nothing to credit. If New York treats you as a resident, its tax applies to all of your income, including interest, dividends and capital gains that would otherwise be taxed nowhere at the state level. For a New York City resident, the City tax is added on top.

This is also why these cases are audited. A taxpayer who reports a move from New York to a state with no income tax, while keeping a New York home, is the standard profile for a New York residency audit. See Basics of State Tax Residency Audits and The Second-Home Owner's Tax Trap.

Mistakes That Turn a Nonresident into a Resident

  • Counting nights, not days. New York counts any part of a day. A day trip counts, and so do both the arrival day and the departure day of a visit.
  • Planning to land on exactly 183. One miscounted day, a delayed flight or an unplanned trip puts you over. Leave a margin.
  • Watching only the day count. Staying under the limit defeats statutory residency. It does not settle domicile, and spending more days in New York than in your new home state is evidence against the move.
  • Forgetting the City count. State days and City days are different numbers.
  • Reconstructing the year afterwards. An audit usually arrives a year or more after the tax year ends. Rebuilding 365 days from memory, calendars and card statements is slow, and gaps count against you.

The Records That Settle It

In a residency audit the taxpayer generally has to show where they were, day by day. Auditors commonly ask for cell phone records, credit card and bank statements, E-ZPass and other toll records, airline records, building access logs and calendars. Each of those sources has gaps, and a day you cannot account for may be treated as a New York day.

A contemporaneous location log closes those gaps. It records where you were on every day of the year as it happened, including the days when you made no purchases and took no flights, and it shows the time you entered and left New York on travel days. See Why Excel and Spreadsheets Fail in State Tax Residency Audits.

How Domicile365 Helps

The Domicile365 App records your location automatically and counts presence at any time during a day as a day in that jurisdiction, which matches New York's rule. It keeps separate counts for New York State and New York City alongside your counts for Nevada, Florida or anywhere else, so you can see during the year how many New York days you have used and how your time compares between your two homes. Alerts can warn you as you approach a day limit. You can also test your own facts with the free New York residency calculator.

Frequently Asked Questions

If I have a residence in Nevada and a residence in New York, which state do I pay income tax to?

Nevada has no personal income tax, so the only question is whether New York can treat you as a resident. If you are domiciled in New York, or you keep a permanent place of abode in New York for substantially all of the year and spend 184 days or more there, New York taxes all of your income from every source. If neither test is met, New York taxes only your New York-source income, such as wages for work performed in New York or income from New York real estate.

Can I be treated as a New York resident if my driver's license and voter registration are in Nevada or Florida?

Yes. A license and voter registration are treated as formalities. New York looks at where you actually live your life: the homes you keep, where you spend your time, your business ties, your family, and where you keep the possessions that matter to you. Separately, a person domiciled in another state is still taxed as a New York statutory resident if they keep a qualifying home in New York and spend 184 days or more there.

How many days can I spend in New York if I keep my New York home?

If you are not domiciled in New York, the statutory residency test is met at 184 days or more in a year in which you maintain a permanent place of abode in New York for substantially all of the year. Any part of a day in New York generally counts as a full day. Staying under the limit does not settle the separate question of domicile, and time spent in New York is one of the factors used to decide domicile.

Does it matter that my other home is in a state with no income tax?

It raises the stakes. New York gives its residents a credit for income tax paid to another state on income sourced there. Nevada and Florida charge no personal income tax, so there is nothing to credit: if New York treats you as a resident, its tax applies to all of your income, including investment income, with no offset.

Are New York City days counted separately?

Yes. New York City applies the same two tests using a home and days in the five boroughs. A person can be a New York State resident without being a City resident, for example with a home in the Hamptons or Westchester, so State days and City days should be tracked separately.

Conclusion

With a home in New York and a home in Nevada or Florida, you are a New York nonresident only if both things are true: your domicile has really moved, and you either gave up the New York home or stayed at 183 days or fewer. Both are questions of fact, the taxpayer has to prove them, and the proof is a record of where you were each day. This article is general information, not tax advice; consult your tax advisor about your specific facts.


Defend Your Residency Status

Don't rely on inadequate records. Use the Domicile365 App to create a defensible, GPS-based log of your location.
Sign up for a free 60-day trial and start tracking today.